{"id":2513,"date":"2023-01-04T19:33:59","date_gmt":"2023-01-05T00:33:59","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/coevolving.com\/blogs\/?p=2513"},"modified":"2023-01-19T12:05:13","modified_gmt":"2023-01-19T17:05:13","slug":"world-hypotheses-contextualism-systems-methods","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"http:\/\/coevolving.com\/blogs\/world-hypotheses-contextualism-systems-methods\/","title":{"rendered":"World Hypotheses, Contextualism, Systems Methods"},"content":{"rendered":"<p>The first <a href=\"https:\/\/wiki.st-on.org\/home\">Systems Thinking Ontario<\/a> session for 2023 is scheduled for <a href=\"https:\/\/wiki.st-on.org\/2023-01-09\">January 9, on &#8220;Root Metaphors and World Hypotheses&#8221;<\/a>.\u00a0 This is philosophical content, for which a guided tour and discussion will be better than attempting a solo reading of the <a href=\"http:\/\/wh.daviding.wiki.openlearning.cc\/view\/welcome-visitors\/view\/world-hypotheses\">World Hypotheses wiki on the Open Learning Commons<\/a>.\u00a0 Upon announcing the session on social media, I was honoured to receive <a href=\"https:\/\/www.linkedin.com\/feed\/update\/urn:li:activity:7015730114118246400?commentUrn=urn%3Ali%3Acomment%3A%28activity%3A7015730114118246400%2C7015754029347520512%29\">a response<\/a> from <a href=\"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/profile\/Michael-Jackson-37\">Michael C. Jackson, OBE<\/a>.<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>Very interesting, David. And great that you are bringing Pepper and Emery\/Trist back into centre of debates about systems thinking &#8211; where they belong.<\/p>\n<p>Thanks, also, for drawing attention to <a href=\"http:\/\/wh.daviding.wiki.openlearning.cc\/view\/theoretical-contribution-of-world-hypotheses-to-critical-systems-thinking\">my 2020 discussion of world hypotheses<\/a>.<\/p>\n<p>Sociotechnical thinking went through a brief \u2018mechanical systems\u2019 phase (<a href=\"#trist_bamforth_1951\">Trist and Bamforth<\/a>) before discovering von Bertalanffy and embracing organicism. It is also true that both Trist and Emery later claimed to have moved beyond organicism and embraced contextualism.<\/p>\n<p>My own view is that they did not succeed and that organicism continued to dominate in the <a href=\"#emery_trist_1965\">L22 work<\/a> and even in the later socio-ecological work.<\/p>\n<p>I recently had an exchange with Merrylyn Emery on this who, of course, says I am wrong and that her and Fred\u2019s later work is clearly contextualist.<\/p>\n<p>My argument, which I still adhere to, can be found in the <a href=\"#jackson_2019\">chapter on sociotechnical thinking in my \u2018Critical Systems Thinking and the Management of Complexity\u2019<\/a>. It is this chapter Merrylyn objected to. She is still very active in Australia.<\/p>\n<p>Best wishes, Mike.<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p>For those with a deeper curiosity, the chapter that Mike mentions is <em>Part III<\/em>: Systems Practice, <em>Type D<\/em>: Systems Approaches for Organizational Complexity, <a href=\"#jackson_2019\"><em>Chapter 12<\/em>: Socio\u2010Technical Systems Thinking<\/a>, pages 261-290 in the 720-page book.<\/p>\n<p>In section 12.2.2 <em>Philosophy and Theory<\/em>, Jackson provides an historical overview of the evolution of the Socio-Technical Systems perspective at the Tavistock Institute, that dates back to the original British coal mine studies of <a href=\"#trist_bamforth_1951\">Trist and Bamforth (1951)<\/a>.\u00a0 In the decades that followed, theory and practices were updated from experiences.<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>Partly as a result of reflecting on the failure of STS initiatives to sustain themselves and to proliferate as widely as expected, Emery and Trist had moved on as well.<\/p>\n<p>In the 1970s, they began to concentrate on developing \u201cchange strategies\u201d that would help organizations accept the \u201cnew paradigm\u201d of thinking needed to cope in increasingly \u201c<a href=\"#emery_trist_1965\">turbulent environments<\/a>.\u201d Their major concern became organizational purposes, values, and philosophies (<a href=\"#trist_1981\">Trist 1981<\/a>, p. 45).<\/p>\n<p>The theoretical groundwork was laid in the book <em>On Purposeful Systems<\/em> (<a href=\"#ackoff_emery_1972\">Ackoff and Emery 1972<\/a>).<\/p>\n<p>Emery had already been developing the \u201c<a href=\"#emery_1996\">Search Conference<\/a>\u201d as a methodology for operating at this level.<\/p>\n<p>Trist joined Ackoff at the Wharton School, University of Pennsylvania, in 1969 and worked with him on the influential <a href=\"https:\/\/coevolving.com\/blogs\/index.php\/archive\/beyond-the-tavistock-and-s-cubed-legacy\/\">\u201cSocial Systems Sciences\u201d (S\u2010cubed) program<\/a> until his nominal retirement in 1978.<\/p>\n<p>In the 1990s, Emery and his wife Merrelyn, working in Australia, continued to run Search Conferences and added the \u201c<a href=\"#emery_emery_1993\">Participative Design Workshop<\/a>\u201d to the armory of STS methods. Merrelyn Emery has stayed with these endeavors since Fred\u2019s death in 1997.<\/p>\n<p>The fact that Trist and Emery worked so closely with Ackoff (see Chapter 15) indicates a radical reorientation in their thinking which will be reviewed in what follows. The continued relevance of the traditional version of STS will be considered in Section 12.5. [p. 268, editorial paragraphing added]<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p>The &#8220;nominal retirement&#8221; of Eric Trist saw him <a href=\"https:\/\/coevolving.com\/blogs\/index.php\/archive\/trist-in-canada-organizational-change-action-learning\/\">at York University in Toronto, Canada 1978-1983<\/a>.<\/p>\n<p>In section 12.4 <em>Critique of Socio-Technical Systems Thinking<\/em>, Jackson writes about the transition from an organicism (world hypothesis) into a reformation.\u00a0 Criticisms of the Socio-Technical Systems approach surfaced with a series of articles published in leading systems journals from 2008 to 2011.\u00a0 The criticisms and responses are familiar to me, as I met the authors in a course on <a href=\"https:\/\/coevolving.com\/blogs\/index.php\/archive\/socio-technical-systems-sustainable-work-open-systems-theor\/\">&#8220;Socio-Technical Systems Paradigm: History and Further Developments&#8221; in fall 2010 at Aalto University<\/a>.\u00a0 Jackson first describes the argument put forth in 2008.<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>There is an important question around whether the criticisms leveled against the organismic version of STS also carry weight against the later \u201cpurposeful systems\u201d variant.<\/p>\n<p>An interesting debate in the pages of <em>Systems Research and Behavioral Science<\/em> illuminates but does not entirely settle the issue. <a href=\"#kira_vaneijnatten_2008\">Kira and van Eijnatten (2008)<\/a> started the ball rolling by claiming that their \u201cchaordic systems approach\u201d offers a superior way of achieving socially sustainable work organizations than traditional STS. We will restrict ourselves to their criticisms of STS.<\/p>\n<p>STS is labeled as \u201cfunctionalist\u201d; specifically as being positivist\/objectivist in methodological terms and seeing causality as simple to untangle. It is then portrayed as having four major weaknesses.<\/p>\n<ul>\n<li>First, STS is guilty of \u201cshaping work and organization toward a predefined goal through predefined paths\u201d (p. 746) and largely ignoring the spontaneous way work organization develops in the course of stakeholder interaction.<\/li>\n<li>Second, it is inconsistent because it falls into the \u201cKantian split\u201d that Stacey sees as bedeviling all systems approaches. Managers are perceived, using a rationalist teleological framework, as capable of making intentional choices to improve organizations, while workers are viewed, using a formative teleological framework, as objects to be controlled for the greater good of the whole enterprise (see Section 7.6). The essential role employees can play is organizational development is therefore neglected.<\/li>\n<li>Third, STS is accused of wanting to hold organizations in a steady state, using feedback control, rather than in the \u201cmultiple, more complex equilibrium states\u201d (p. 746) necessary to promote sustainability.<\/li>\n<li>Finally, STS forgets that the process of achieving sustainability goals is just as important as the goals themselves. It is essential to continually engage en route with stakeholder values and worldviews to encourage learning and the emergence of novelty. [p. 284, editorial paragraphing added]<\/li>\n<\/ul>\n<\/blockquote>\n<p>With the 2008 paper elevating &#8220;a migration into chaordic systems thinking (ChST)&#8221;, the criticisms that &#8220;traditional socio-technical systems (STSs) approaches do not offer optimal foundations for achieving sustainability&#8221; were harsh.<\/p>\n<p>Having met Kira and van Eijnatten in fall 2010, I gained greater insight into the work of Merrelyn Emery in spring 2012, in a 5-day <a href=\"http:\/\/archive-ifsr.org\/2012\/04\/19\/proceedings-of-the-ifsr-conversation-2012-st-magdalena-linz\/\">IFSR Conversation<\/a> in Austria. The proceedings report on &#8220;<a href=\"https:\/\/coevolving.com\/commons\/201209-revisiting-the-socio-ecological-social-technical-and-socio-psychological-perspectives\">Revisiting the Socio-ecological, Social-technical and Socio-psychological Perspectives<\/a>&#8221; was led by <a href=\"https:\/\/scholar.google.com\/citations?user=TFltBKoAAAAJ\">Minna Takala<\/a>, with contributions from <a href=\"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/profile\/Merrelyn-Emery-2\">Merrelyn Emery<\/a>, <a href=\"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/profile\/Debora-Hammond-2\">Debora Hammond<\/a>, <a href=\"http:\/\/garymetcalf.com\/interconnectionsllc\/2000\/07\/about-gary-metcalf\/\">Gary S. Metcalf<\/a> and myself.<\/p>\n<p>Continuing in section 12.4 <em>Critique of Socio-Technical Systems Thinking<\/em>, Jackson supports the 2010 refutation written by Merrelyn Emery, suggesting that the four major weaknesses listed by Kira and van Eijnatten might be viewed from the work of <a href=\"http:\/\/wh.daviding.wiki.openlearning.cc\/view\/welcome-visitors\/view\/stephen-c-pepper\">Stephen C. Pepper<\/a> in <a href=\"http:\/\/wh.daviding.wiki.openlearning.cc\/view\/welcome-visitors\/view\/world-hypotheses\"><em>World Hypotheses<\/em><\/a> (1942).<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>Merrelyn Emery is, quite reasonably in my view, aggrieved (<a href=\"#emery_2010\">Emery M. 2010<\/a>) and is not placated by <a href=\"#kira_vaneijnatten_2010\">Kira and van Eijnatten\u2019s (2010)<\/a> claim that their criticisms are aimed more at the earlier type of STS than the Emerys\u2019 later \u201copen\u2010systems thinking\u201d (OST) (<a href=\"#emery_2011\">Emery M. 2011<\/a>).<\/p>\n<p>In her view, any plausible critique has to take into account the significant developments made by the \u201cpurposeful systems\u201d type of STS pioneered by Trist, her husband Fred Emery and herself.<\/p>\n<ul>\n<li>Emery argues that OST, embracing the work on the \u201ccausal texture of organizational environments,\u201d the \u201cgenotypical organizational design principles,\u201d \u201cparticipative design workshops\u201d (PDW), and \u201csearch conferences,\u201d learned from past mistakes and situates STS in a different paradigm, OST.<\/li>\n<li>Emery argues, does not impose predetermined designs, treats all people, including workers, as open, purposeful systems, facilitates debates about human values, and encourages the coevolution of the organization with its environment as stakeholders develop their ideal\u2010seeking capabilities and translate them into strategic plans.<\/li>\n<li>According to <a href=\"#emery_2010\">Emery M. (2010<\/a>, p. 701), a fundamental shift in paradigm has taken place that makes the old sort of STS \u201cobsolete,\u201d and Kira and van Eijnatten\u2019s criticisms of STS, based on that version, misplaced.<\/li>\n<\/ul>\n<p>The change, using Pepper\u2019s theory of different \u201croot metaphors,\u201d is from the \u201cworld hypothesis of organicism,\u201d which champions the \u201cintegration\u201d of parts in whole systems, to the \u201ccontextualist world hypothesis,\u201d which deals with the historic act in its context, accommodates purposeful behavior, and can produce and explain \u201cnovelty and emergence.\u201d<\/p>\n<p>As Fred <a href=\"#emery_1969\">Emery (1969<\/a>, p. 15) remarked, all Pepper\u2019s \u201croot metaphors\u201d are in operation in different systems theories and the result is much mutual incomprehension. Kira and van Eijnatten\u2019s critique certainly struggles to find its mark when aimed at the \u201cpurposeful systems\u201d version of STS [pp. 284-285, editorial paragraphing added].<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p>In my personal library, I happen to own a copy of the rare Penguin paperback <em>Systems Thinking: Selected Readings<\/em>, 1969 original edition, (as well as the more commonly found 1978 revised edition).\u00a0 The mention by Jackson leads me to look up the Part One section description single page. It says that excerpts of Pepper&#8217;s writing were omitted in the collection of articles, because the paperback is already 400 pages in length!<br \/>\n<a id=\"precedents\"><\/a><\/p>\n<blockquote><p><em>Part One<\/em> <strong>Precedents to Systems Theory<\/strong><\/p>\n<p>[&#8230;.]<\/p>\n<p>Only pressing problems of space precluded a selection from S. C. Pepper (1950). This is of particular importance because the &#8216;root metaphors&#8217; he identifies and rigorously defines are all clearly operating in different systems theorists and account for much of the mutual incomprehension that exists among them. &#8216;Contextualism&#8217; is the root metaphor which comes closest to our bias in selecting for this volume.<\/p>\n<p><strong>References<\/strong><\/p>\n<p>PEPPER, S. C. (1950), World Hypotheses, University of California.\u00a0 [<a href=\"#emery_1969\">Emery (1969)<\/a> p. 15]<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p>So, a pursuit of rethinking systems thinking wouldn&#8217;t be hurt by a closer reading of <em>World Hypotheses<\/em> (1942)!<\/p>\n<p>On the refutation by Merrelyn Emery, Jackson says that he, himself, has corrected an error similar to that commited by Kira and van Eijnatten.<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>One of the aims of critical systems thinking is to eliminate incomprehension and encourage mutual understanding and respect among advocates of the different branches of the systems approach.<\/p>\n<ul>\n<li>To that end, let us continue this second\u2010order analysis of STS by relating it to the system of systems methodologies (SOSM). Early attempts to do this (<a href=\"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/243768021_Towards_a_System_of_Systems_Methodologies\">Jackson and Keys 1984<\/a>; <a href=\"https:\/\/doi.org\/10.1007\/b100327\">Jackson 2000<\/a>), as <a style=\"outline-width: 0px !important; user-select: auto !important;\" href=\"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/227290691_Tracking_the_development_of_the_Emery-Trist_systems_paradigm_ETSP\">Baburoglu (1992)<\/a> points out, made the same mistake as Kira and van Eijnatten by treating STS as a unified paradigm and concentrating on the earlier organismic formulation.<\/li>\n<li>I plead guilty and will seek to provide a richer appreciation of the approach in what follows. Baburoglu identifies four tracks within STS, or what he calls the \u201cEmery\u2010Trist Systems Paradigm,\u201d on the basis of \u201ca liberation theme.\u201d<\/li>\n<\/ul>\n<p>While we will stick with the simpler categorization into \u201corganismic\u201d and \u201cpurposeful systems\u201d variants, we will use his work to add further depth to the analysis.\u00a0 [p. 285, editorial paragraphing added]<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p>Jackson, in his reworked <a href=\"#jackson_2020_understand\">System of Systems Methodologies<\/a>, places the organicist Socio-Technical Systems thinking approach as complex-unitary.<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>In terms of the reworked SOSM, the organismic version of STS makes \u201ccomplex\u201d assumptions about systems and their environments.<\/p>\n<p>It certainly does not regard causality, <em>pace<\/em> Kira and van Eijnatten, as simple and easy to grasp. Rather it sees internal interrelationships as potentially giving rise to emergent properties and the environment as changing and unpredictable.<\/p>\n<p>The recommendations made concern how systems should be designed to be responsive and capable of learning so that they can evolve appropriately over time as they are affected by their own parts and by the turbulent environments in which they exist.<\/p>\n<p>This last point distinguishes STS from system dynamics, which we labeled as making \u201ccomplicated\u201d assumptions because it takes an endogenous point of view and seeks to map the myriad interrelationships between all the variables impacting system behavior.<\/p>\n<p>In respect of the \u201cstakeholders\u201d dimension of the SOSM, the organismic form of STS clearly makes \u201cunitary\u201d assumptions. This is explicitly the case when the \u201cprimary task\u201d of the organization is defined as the task it was set up to perform or must undertake in order to survive.<\/p>\n<p>Even when it becomes accepted that multiple primary tasks can exist, there is an implicit assumption that all areas of the organization can reach an agreement on what the overarching objective should be. Little thought is given, in this version of STS, to how this agreement can be reached. As Fred Emery stated, in the Norwegian Industrial Democracy project, the workers were required to \u201ctrust\u201d the consultants. [p. 285, editorial paragraphing added]<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<figure id=\"attachment_2517\" aria-describedby=\"caption-attachment-2517\" style=\"width: 600px\" class=\"wp-caption alignnone\"><a href=\"http:\/\/coevolving.com\/blogs\/wp-content\/uploads\/2023\/01\/2019_Jackson_Figure_12-1.png\" rel=\"lightbox[2513]\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" class=\"size-full wp-image-2517\" src=\"http:\/\/coevolving.com\/blogs\/wp-content\/uploads\/2023\/01\/2019_Jackson_Figure_12-1.png\" alt=\"Jackson (2019) Figure 12.1\" width=\"600\" height=\"360\" srcset=\"http:\/\/coevolving.com\/blogs\/wp-content\/uploads\/2023\/01\/2019_Jackson_Figure_12-1.png 600w, http:\/\/coevolving.com\/blogs\/wp-content\/uploads\/2023\/01\/2019_Jackson_Figure_12-1-475x285.png 475w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 600px) 100vw, 600px\" \/><\/a><figcaption id=\"caption-attachment-2517\" class=\"wp-caption-text\">Figure 12.1 The positioning of Socio\u2010Technical Systems Thinking on the SOSM [<a href=\"#jackson_2019\">Jackson 2019<\/a>]<\/figcaption><\/figure>\n<blockquote><p>The approach shows very little interest in organizational politics, conflict, or issues of power and coercion. Nevertheless this \u201cfirst developmental track\u201d of STS, as Baburoglu calls it, does offer to employees \u201cliberation from the domination of the machine\u201d and \u201cliberation from single and meaningless tasks and from external control\u201d (<a href=\"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/227290691_Tracking_the_development_of_the_Emery-Trist_systems_paradigm_ETSP\">1992<\/a>, p. 287). In summary, the organismic version of STS can reasonably be represented as making \u201ccomplex\u2010unitary\u201d assumptions and positioned on the SOSM as in Figure 12.1.\u00a0 [p. 286]<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p>On this SOSM positioning of the organicist version of Socio-Technical Systems thinking as complex-unitary, it&#8217;s likely that Merrelyn Emery would have few objections.\u00a0 However, the next paragraph on the evolved approach is likely where Merrelyn would claim a pluralist-complex positioning.\u00a0 Jackson continues:<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>It should now be asked whether the \u201cpurposeful systems\u201d version of STS requires a different positioning on the SOSM. Emery argues that OST marks a paradigm break with the earlier formulation. In Baburoglu\u2019s account it opens up two more \u201cdevelopmental tracks\u201d for STS &#8212; one offering \u201cliberation of the futures\u201d and \u201cliberation from the expert and expertise\u201d; and another promising \u201cliberation from single social system referential design\u201d and \u201cliberation from institutional and organizational constraints on individuals\u201d (<a href=\"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/227290691_Tracking_the_development_of_the_Emery-Trist_systems_paradigm_ETSP\">1992<\/a>, p. 287). Both seem to demand that this version should be recognized as fully appreciating the challenges posed by pluralistic contexts. A couple of points give me pause however. Without digging too far into the detail, I think OST retains a \u201cwhiff\u201d of functionalism about it. If the first purpose of OST (see Section 12.2.2) is to \u201cpromote and create toward a world that is consciously designed by people, and for people,\u201d the second purpose is<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>&#8230; to develop an internally consistent conceptual framework or social science, within which each component is operationally defined and hypotheses are testable so that the knowledge to support the first purpose is created. (<a href=\"#emery_2000\">Emery M. 2000<\/a>, p. 623) [p. 287]<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p>Not necessarily a bad thing, of course, but it does suggest that a \u201ccomplex\u2010pluralistic\u201d positioning on the SOSM is problematic. I am influenced here by Kira and van Eijnatten\u2019s critique which, in one respect at least, finds the mark. They argue that STS is guilty of \u201cshaping work and organization toward a predefined goal through predefined paths.\u201d If one looks closely at how PDWs and Search Conferences are meant to run, and the kinds of outcomes to which they are intended to give rise, then one finds many \u201csocio\u2010technical\u201d principles accepted without question. In PDWs, we find the job\u2010design principles and the desirability of democratic structures; in Search Conferences, it is easy to identify participative planning, self\u2010managed groups, and particular dissemination practices. [p. 287]<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p>While the label of &#8220;systems thinking&#8221; is often used as a catch-all phrase, it may be important here to separate out &#8220;systems theory&#8221; from &#8220;systems methods&#8221;.<\/p>\n<ul>\n<li>Causal texture is a systems theory.\u00a0 DP1 and DP2 (Design Principle 1 and Design Principle 2) relate to human social systems, as theory.<\/li>\n<li>Search Conference and Participatory Design Workshops are systems methods, applied with human social systems.<\/li>\n<\/ul>\n<p>Russell Ackoff would make the distinction between <a href=\"https:\/\/coevolving.com\/blogs\/index.php\/archive\/system-types-as-purposeful-and-displaying-choice\/\">four system types<\/a>:\u00a0 deterministic, animated, social and ecological, based on purposefulness in the wholes and parts.\u00a0 Methods appropriate for one system type might not be appropriate for another type, even if a theoretical understanding across all systems types were attained.<\/p>\n<p>In Jackson&#8217;s view, espousing a contextualist theoretical position while continuing to apply organicist methods is problematic.<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>If these socio\u2010technical \u201ccertainties\u201d are smuggled in, and have to be accepted, then are we really achieving the sorts of \u201cliberation\u201d Baburoglu claims for the new developmental tracks? It is true that OST has much that is new to offer, especially with regard to the implementation of STS. But it does not seem that a clean break with \u201corganicism\u201d has been made and that \u201ccontextualism\u201d has been fully embraced. <a href=\"#barton_selsky_2000\">Barton and Selsky (2000)<\/a> concur that there is an \u201cessentialist stance\u201d in OST in which environments are concrete and people can perceive them directly without the need for abstract concepts. The same conclusion can be reached from a different direction. If we remove the organismic principles embedded in the PDW and Search Conference methodologies, what do we have left? I would suggest that we have significantly underdeveloped forms of the kind of soft systems approach that will be studied later. It was left to Ackoff (see Chapter 15), who had worked closely with Emery and Trist, to make the clean paradigm break that eluded STS. This is, of course, for better or worse depending on the observer. [p. 287]<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p>So, could a complex-pluralistic systems theory in the SOSM framework be derived from the heritage of Fred E. Emery and Eric L. Trist?\u00a0 Mike Jackson wrote &#8230;<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>&#8230; both Trist and Emery later claimed to have moved beyond organicism and embraced contextualism.<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p>Some details in the root metaphors and world hypotheses of Stephen C. Pepper can provide some illumination.<\/p>\n<p>From the four <a href=\"http:\/\/wh.daviding.wiki.openlearning.cc\/view\/welcome-visitors\/view\/relatively-adequate-hypotheses\">relatively adequate hypotheses<\/a> listed in <em>World Hypotheses<\/em> (1942),<\/p>\n<ul>\n<li><a href=\"http:\/\/wh.daviding.wiki.openlearning.cc\/view\/welcome-visitors\/view\/relatively-adequate-hypotheses\/view\/contextualism\">contextualism<\/a> has the root metaphor of the <em>historic event<\/em>, also known as the <em>act in context<\/em>, or <em>situation; and<\/em><\/li>\n<li><a href=\"http:\/\/wh.daviding.wiki.openlearning.cc\/view\/welcome-visitors\/view\/relatively-adequate-hypotheses\/view\/organicism\">organicism<\/a> has the root metaphor of <em>integration<\/em>, in processes of <em>organic development.<\/em><\/li>\n<\/ul>\n<p>Decades later, in <a href=\"http:\/\/wh.daviding.wiki.openlearning.cc\/view\/welcome-visitors\/view\/concept-and-quality-1966\"><em>Concept and Quality<\/em> (1966)<\/a>, Stephen C. Pepper proposed a fifth world hypothesis,<\/p>\n<ul>\n<li><a href=\"http:\/\/wh.daviding.wiki.openlearning.cc\/view\/welcome-visitors\/view\/concept-and-quality-1966\/view\/selectivism\">selectivism<\/a>, with a root metaphor of the <em>purposive act<\/em>.<\/li>\n<\/ul>\n<p>Bill Harrell wrote that Pepper himself had not decided whether selectivism was a completely new world hypothesis, or an extension of contextualism.<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>[204] He considered this study a sequel to <em>World Hypotheses<\/em> but did not believe it supplanted the earlier work. The four world hypotheses were basically adequate and he still could not identify a cognitively responsible means of choosing one over the other. Selectivism was a fifth and new world theory or possibly a radical revision of one of the original hypothesis, contextualism. This new world hypothesis has the same cognitive status as the others and bears the same relationship to the others as they do one to the other. That said, it is fairly apparent that Pepper was convinced that selectivism handled many of the problems the others could not resolve.\u00a0 [<a href=\"#harrell_2004\">Harrell, 2004<\/a>]<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p>Based on the root metaphors, the <em>purposive act<\/em> of <em>selectivism<\/em> would seem closer to Merrelyn Emery&#8217;s view of the evolved Open Systems Theory tradition.\u00a0 If selectivism is seem as a revision of contextualism, then the purposive act as a root metaphor for OST makes some sense.<\/p>\n<p>The alternative view would be the recognition that the Emery branch of the 1960s Tavistock Institute diverged in later years from that Eric Trist, in North America.\u00a0 From the 2012 IFSR Conversation:<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>According to Merrelyn, the strict reliance on Angyal\u2019s, Sommerhoff\u2019s and Emery &amp; Trist\u2019s formulations distinguished the work that she did with Fred Emery and others in Australia from later work by Trist or Ackoff.<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>We stuck with the time-based Search Conference where probabilities of various scenarios change over time while Ackoff went with time-free \u2018idealized design\u2019 (<a href=\"https:\/\/archive.org\/details\/redesigningfutur00russ\/mode\/2up\">Ackoff, 1974<\/a>, p30). Neither Ackoff nor Trist ever used the design principles which underpinned all our work (<a href=\"https:\/\/doi.org\/10.1177\/002188638602200304\">Trist, 1986<\/a>). The Australian group stayed with Angyal\u2019s system principle, the unique relation between L22 and L11, and the organizational design principles that determine the shape of the L11&#8230;while Trist worked on referent organizations and domain theory (<a href=\"https:\/\/doi.org\/10.1177\/001872678303600304\">Trist, 1983<\/a>) (pp. 3-4).\u00a0 [<a href=\"#takala_2012\">Takala 2012<\/a>, p. 10]<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<\/blockquote>\n<p>While Fred E. Emery returned to Australia, Eric Trist continued research in North America , moving on to inter-organizational domains.\u00a0 As compared to organizational wholes where an organicist world hypothesis makes sense, cooperation across organizational boundaries (e.g. in <a href=\"http:\/\/openinnovationlearning.com\/online\/\">open sourcing communities<\/a>) are better appreciated through\u00a0 contextualism.<\/p>\n<p>The <a href=\"http:\/\/moderntimesworkplace.com\/archives\/ericsess\/ericsess.html\">Tavistock Anthology<\/a> was released as 3 volumes:\u00a0 the Socio-Psychological Systems perspective, the Socio-Technical Systems perspective, and the Socio-Ecological Systems perspective.\u00a0 The philosophical foundations under each need not have been uniform.\u00a0 Contextualism has a history as the philosophical foundation for Socio-Ecological Systems.<\/p>\n<h3>References<\/h3>\n<p><a id=\"ackoff_emery_1972\"><\/a>Ackoff, Russell L., and Fred E. Emery. 1972. <em>On Purposeful Systems<\/em>. Aldine-Atherton. [<a href=\"https:\/\/doi.org\/10.4324\/9781315125640\">republished by Routledge in 2017<\/a>]<\/p>\n<p><a id=\"barton_selsky_2000\"><\/a>Barton, John, and John W. Selsky. 2000. \u201cAfterword: Toward an Emery Model of Management: Implications and Prospects of Emery Open Systems Theory.\u201d <em>Systemic Practice and Action Research<\/em> 13 (5): 705\u201320. <a href=\"https:\/\/doi.org\/10.1023\/A:1009585711789\">https:\/\/doi.org\/10.1023\/A:1009585711789<\/a>.<\/p>\n<p><a id=\"emery_trist_1965\"><\/a>Emery, Fred E., and Eric L. Trist. 1965. \u201cThe Causal Texture of Organizational Environments.\u201d <em>Human Relations<\/em> 18 (1): 21\u201332. <a href=\"https:\/\/doi.org\/10.1177\/001872676501800103\">https:\/\/doi.org\/10.1177\/001872676501800103<\/a>.<\/p>\n<p><a id=\"emery_1969\"><\/a>Emery, Fred E. 1969. \u201cPrecedents to Systems Theory.\u201d In <em>Systems Thinking: Selected Readings<\/em>, edited by Fred E. Emery, 1st ed., 1:15. Penguin. <a href=\"http:\/\/books.google.ca\/books?id=G2tHAAAAMAAJ\">http:\/\/books.google.ca\/books?id=G2tHAAAAMAAJ<\/a>.<\/p>\n<p><a id=\"emery_emery_1993\"><\/a>Emery, Fred E., and Merrelyn Emery. 1993. \u201cThe Participative Design Workshop.\u201d In <em>The Social Engagement of Social Science<\/em>, edited by Eric L. Trist and Hugh Murray, Project MUSE, Vol. 2 The Socio-Technical Perspective:599\u2013613. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press. <a href=\"https:\/\/muse.jhu.edu\/chapter\/1775974\">https:\/\/muse.jhu.edu\/chapter\/1775974<\/a>.<\/p>\n<p><a id=\"emery_1996\"><\/a>Emery, Merrelyn. 1996. \u201cThe Search Conference: Design and Management of Learning.\u201d In <em>The Social Engagement of Social Science<\/em>, edited by Beulah Trist, Hugh Murray, and Eric L. Trist, Project MUSE. Vol. 3 The Socio-Ecological Perspective. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press. <a href=\"https:\/\/muse.jhu.edu\/chapter\/1755586\">https:\/\/muse.jhu.edu\/chapter\/1755586<\/a>.<\/p>\n<p><a id=\"emery_2010\"><\/a>Emery, Merrelyn. 2010. \u201cRefutation of Kira &amp; van Eijnatten\u2019s Critique of the Emery\u2019s Open Systems Theory.\u201d <em>Systems Research and Behavioral Science<\/em> 27 (6): 697\u2013712. <a href=\"https:\/\/doi.org\/10.1002\/sres.1010\">https:\/\/doi.org\/10.1002\/sres.1010<\/a>.<\/p>\n<p><a id=\"emery_2011\"><\/a>Emery, Merrelyn. 2011. \u201cFiddling While the Planet Burns: The Scientific Validity of Chaordic Systems Thinking.\u201d <em>Systems Research and Behavioral Science<\/em> 28 (4): 401\u201317. <a href=\"https:\/\/doi.org\/10.1002\/sres.1091\">https:\/\/doi.org\/10.1002\/sres.1091<\/a>.<\/p>\n<p><a id=\"harrell_2004\"><\/a>Harrell, Bill J. 2004. \u201cFive World Hypotheses: A Primer on Stephen C. Pepper\u2019s Epistemological System With Illustrations from the Arts, Humanities, Social, and Natural Sciences.\u201d Internet Archive. <a href=\"https:\/\/web.archive.org\/web\/20041110053845\/http:\/\/people.sunyit.edu:80\/~harrell\/Pepper\/bjh_pep01.htm\">https:\/\/web.archive.org\/web\/20041110053845\/http:\/\/people.sunyit.edu:80\/~harrell\/Pepper\/bjh_pep01.htm<\/a>.<\/p>\n<p><a id=\"jackson_2019\"><\/a>Jackson, Michael C. 2019. \u201cSocio\u2010Technical Systems Thinking.\u201d In <em>Critical Systems Thinking and the Management of Complexity<\/em>, 263\u201390. John Wiley &amp; Sons. <a href=\"https:\/\/www.wiley.com\/en-ca\/Critical+Systems+Thinking+and+the+Management+of+Complexity-p-9781119118398\">https:\/\/www.wiley.com\/en-ca\/Critical+Systems+Thinking+and+the+Management+of+Complexity-p-9781119118398<\/a>.<\/p>\n<p><a id=\"jackson_2020_critical\"><\/a>Jackson, Michael C. 2020. \u201cCritical Systems Practice 1: Explore &#8212; Starting a Multimethodological Intervention.\u201d <em>Systems Research and Behavioral Science<\/em> 37 (5): 839\u201358. <a href=\"https:\/\/doi.org\/10.1002\/sres.2746\">https:\/\/doi.org\/10.1002\/sres.2746<\/a>. cached on the <a href=\"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/project\/Critical-Systems-Thinking-2\/update\/634420e50c295f1f9adadb05\">ResearchGate Project on &#8220;Critical Systems Thinking&#8221;<\/a>.<\/p>\n<p><a id=\"jackson_2020_understand\"><\/a>Jackson, Michael C. 2020. \u201cHow We Understand \u2018Complexity\u2019 Makes a Difference: Lessons from Critical Systems Thinking and the Covid-19 Pandemic in the UK.\u201d <em>Systems<\/em> 8 (4): 52. <a href=\"https:\/\/doi.org\/10.3390\/systems8040052\">https:\/\/doi.org\/10.3390\/systems8040052<\/a>.<\/p>\n<p><a id=\"kira_vaneijnatten_2008\"><\/a>Kira, Mari, and Frans M. van Eijnatten. 2008. \u201cSocially Sustainable Work Organizations: A Chaordic Systems Approach.\u201d <em>Systems Research and Behavioral Science<\/em> 25 (6): 743\u201356. <a href=\"https:\/\/doi.org\/10.1002\/sres.896\">https:\/\/doi.org\/10.1002\/sres.896<\/a>.<\/p>\n<p><a id=\"kira_vaneijnatten_2010\"><\/a>Kira, Mari, and Frans M. van Eijnatten. 2010. \u201cSocially Sustainable Work Organizations and Systems Thinking.\u201d <em>Systems Research and Behavioral Science<\/em> 27 (6): 713\u201321. <a href=\"https:\/\/doi.org\/10.1002\/sres.1043\">https:\/\/doi.org\/10.1002\/sres.1043<\/a>.<\/p>\n<p><a id=\"takala_2012\"><\/a>Takala, Minna. 2012. \u201cRevisiting the Socio-Ecological, Social-Technical and Socio-Psychological Perspectives.\u201d In <em>Systems for Education, Engineering, Serivce and Sustainability &#8212; Proceedings of the Sixteenth IFSR Conversation<\/em>, edited by Gerhard Chroust and Gary S. Metcalf, 5\u201324. Linz, Austria: International Federation for Systems Research. <a href=\"https:\/\/coevolving.com\/commons\/201209-revisiting-the-socio-ecological-social-technical-and-socio-psychological-perspectives\">https:\/\/coevolving.com\/commons\/201209-revisiting-the-socio-ecological-social-technical-and-socio-psychological-perspectives<\/a>.<\/p>\n<p><a id=\"trist_bamforth_1951\"><\/a>Trist, E. L, and K. W Bamforth. 1951. \u201cSome Social and Psychological Consequences of the Longwall Method of Coal-Getting.\u201d <em>Human Relations<\/em>. <em>https:\/\/doi.org\/10.1177\/001872675100400101<\/em>.<\/p>\n<p><a id=\"trist_1981\"><\/a>]Trist, Eric L. 1981. The Evolution of Socio-Technical Systems: A Conceptual Framework and Action Research Program. Occasional Paper 2. Toronto, Canada: Ontario Quality of Working Life Centre.\u00a0 [<a href=\"https:\/\/scholar.google.com\/scholar?cluster=14777751206749843700\">search on Google Scholar<\/a>]<\/p>\n<p><a href=\"http:\/\/coevolving.com\/blogs\/wp-content\/uploads\/2023\/01\/20230103_RootMetaphors_Jackson.png\" rel=\"lightbox[2513]\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" class=\"alignnone size-full wp-image-2514\" src=\"http:\/\/coevolving.com\/blogs\/wp-content\/uploads\/2023\/01\/20230103_RootMetaphors_Jackson.png\" alt=\"Response by Dr. Mike C. Jackson OBE\" width=\"571\" height=\"457\" srcset=\"http:\/\/coevolving.com\/blogs\/wp-content\/uploads\/2023\/01\/20230103_RootMetaphors_Jackson.png 571w, http:\/\/coevolving.com\/blogs\/wp-content\/uploads\/2023\/01\/20230103_RootMetaphors_Jackson-475x380.png 475w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 571px) 100vw, 571px\" \/><\/a><\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<p>Comments by Michael C. Jackson OBE on an announcement for a Systems Thinking Ontaroi sessoin on Root Metaphors and World Hypotheses led to an unpacking of intricacies in philosophy, theory and methods.<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":2,"featured_media":0,"comment_status":"open","ping_status":"open","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"activitypub_content_warning":"","activitypub_content_visibility":"","activitypub_max_image_attachments":4,"activitypub_interaction_policy_quote":"anyone","activitypub_status":"","footnotes":""},"categories":[603,12,13],"tags":[651,574,650],"class_list":["post-2513","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","hentry","category-organization","category-practices","category-systems","tag-contextualism","tag-socio-technical-systems","tag-world-hypotheses"],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"http:\/\/coevolving.com\/blogs\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/2513","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"http:\/\/coevolving.com\/blogs\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"http:\/\/coevolving.com\/blogs\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"http:\/\/coevolving.com\/blogs\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/2"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"http:\/\/coevolving.com\/blogs\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=2513"}],"version-history":[{"count":9,"href":"http:\/\/coevolving.com\/blogs\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/2513\/revisions"}],"predecessor-version":[{"id":2538,"href":"http:\/\/coevolving.com\/blogs\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/2513\/revisions\/2538"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"http:\/\/coevolving.com\/blogs\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=2513"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"http:\/\/coevolving.com\/blogs\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=2513"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"http:\/\/coevolving.com\/blogs\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=2513"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}