As teams have been meeting online in preparation for the Problematique Dialogue event in May, there are some questions related to the Banathy Conversation Methodology. There’s an emphasis on generative dialogue, over strategic dialogue.
In the dialogue scholarship community there is a shared understanding that dialogue is not a new tool for addressing specific issues or problems. Rather, it is a means to help people to think together. Dialogue offers an environment where people can create shared meaning. The type of dialogue discussed heretofore is often called “generative,” meaning that it generates a collective worldview. Beck (1994) contrasts generative dialogue with strategic dialogue. According to Beck, strategic dialogue focuses on specific issues and tasks and it is applied in finding specific solutions in organizational and social systems settings. [Banathy (1996), p. 218]
This distinction may be unfamiliar to participants who presume they’re coming together to work towards a solution. One of the 10 characteristics of a wicked problem is that “Every wicked problem can be considered to be a symptom of another problem” [Rittel and Webber 1973, p. 165]. In addition, “For wicked planning problems, there are no true or false answers” [Rittel and Webber 1973, p. 163]. This complexity is prominent in the definition of a problematique.
… Read more (in a new tab)A set of two or more interdependent problems constitutes a system. The French call such a system a problématique; for lack of a corresponding word in English, I call it a mess.
As teams have been meeting online in preparation for the Problematique Dialogue event in May, there are some questions related to the Banathy Conversation Methodology. There’s an emphasis on generative dialogue, over strategic dialogue.
In the dialogue scholarship community there is a shared understanding that dialogue is not a new tool for addressing specific issues or problems. Rather, it is a means to help people to think together. Dialogue offers an environment where people can create shared meaning. The type of dialogue discussed heretofore is often called “generative,” meaning that it generates a collective worldview. Beck (1994) contrasts generative dialogue with strategic dialogue. According to Beck, strategic dialogue focuses on specific issues and tasks and it is applied in finding specific solutions in organizational and social systems settings. [Banathy (1996), p. 218]
This distinction may be unfamiliar to participants who presume they’re coming together to work towards a solution. One of the 10 characteristics of a wicked problem is that “Every wicked problem can be considered to be a symptom of another problem” [Rittel and Webber 1973, p. 165]. In addition, “For wicked planning problems, there are no true or false answers” [Rittel and Webber 1973, p. 163]. This complexity is prominent in the definition of a problematique.
… Read more (in a new tab)A set of two or more interdependent problems constitutes a system. The French call such a system a problématique; for lack of a corresponding word in English, I call it a mess.

