Coevolving Innovations

… in Business Organizations and Information Technologies

Value capture in a global innovation network

With the primaries in the United States making headlines, Americans have been making noises about revisiting NAFTA. Michael Hart and William Dymond provided a Canadian perspective1, with a global perspective on the larger trends.

If our neighbours elect a Democratic president, Senate and House on Nov. 4, things could get ugly, as a falling U.S. dollar, the credit crunch and serious troubles in the housing market add to recession anxieties.

The target for much of that ugliness will be China and other low-cost suppliers to the U.S. consumer market. Most Americans do not have much understanding of the role of these suppliers in maintaining U.S. economic activity. Both politicians and the public fail to realize the benefit of Chinese manufacturing goods produced to U.S. design and using U.S. technology. A recent University of California study found that, of an Apple iPod sold in the U.S. for $299, $160 goes to American companies that design, transport and retail iPods. Only $4 stays in China with the firms that assemble the devices.

I was curious about that $4, and tracked down the report to the Personal Computer Industry Center (PCIC), part of the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation. The paper by Dedrick, Kramer and Linden2 has some interesting tables. Here’s a breakdown from the $299 retail price of the iPod.

Table 5. Derivation of Apple’s Gross Margin on 30GB Video iPod

Retail Price $299  
Distributor Discount
(10%)
($30)  
Retailer Discount
(15%)
($45)  
Sub-Total (estimated
wholesale price)
  $224
Factory Cost ($148)  
Remaining Balance
(estimated Apple gross margin)
  $76

Source: Authors’ calculations; see text

From the above table, follow the $76 estimated gross margin for Apple. The $190 of captured value (profit margin by various participants in the value network) is constructed from the bottom, up.

Table 7. The Distribution of $190 of Captured Value in a Single 30GB Video iPod

  Sales in the U.S Sales outside U.S.
Value Chain Segment Apple All other firms Apple All other firms
Apple Gross Margin
(development, software, marketing
$76   $76  
Parts Suppliers (key
inputs only, Table A-2)
  $35   $35
Manufacturing
(assembly, test)
  $4   $4
Distribution   $30   $30
Retail* $23 $22 $11 $34
TOTAL VALUE CAPTURE $99 $91 $87 $103

*”Retail is split between Apple and other firms based on our estimate that one-half of retail sales in the U.S. and one-quarter of retail sales outside the U.S. are by Apple through its stores and online website. Source: Author’s calculations, see text

The affordability of an iPod to middle class consumers is related to low manufacturing costs (i.e. $4). In the total price of $299, though, there’s a lot of profit that is captured.

For policy makers, here’s how the $190 of captured value breaks out by country of origin.

Table 8. The Geography of $190 of Captured Value in a 30GB Video iPod for a Unit Sold in the U.S.

  U.S. Japan Korea Taiwan Total
Apple Gross Margin
(development, software, marketing
$76       $76
Parts Suppliers (key
inputs only, Table A-2)
$7 $27 $1   $35
Manufacturing
(assembly, test)
      $4 $4
Distribution $30       $30
Retail $45       $45
TOTAL VALUE CAPTURE $158 $27 $1 $4 $190

Note: for this table it is assumed that the unit is sold in the U.S. Source: Authors’ calculations.

Of the $299 price of the iPod, Apple (and the United States) gets $76 as the lead firm in the value chain, plus a potential $45 if the unit is sold directly through its retail channel. Value capture for parts gives $7 to the U.S. (e.g. video/multimedia processor, controller chip), and $27 to Japan (e.g. hard drive, display). Manufacturing (as assembly and test of the unit) results only in $4 of value capture for Taiwan.

This analysis supports advocates of investments in human capital for design and engineering expertise — i.e. university level skills — as opposed to lower-cost manufacturing facilities and roles. Given a choice between value capture in services (i.e. $30 for distribution, $45 for retailing) and manufacturing(i.e. $4), services win. In the global economy, it’s the investment using brainpower, not manual labour, that provides the larger and enduring value capture.


1Michael Hart and William Dymond, “The sabre-rattling on NAFTA is worrying, but take it as an opportunity”, Globe & Mail, March 15, 2008, accessed online at globeandmail.com.2Jason Dedrick, Kenneth L. Kraemer and Greg Linden, “Capturing Value in a Global Innovation Network: A Comparison of Radical and Incremental Innovation”, Personal Computing Industry Center (University of California, Irvine), Paper 407, 2077, accessed online at pcic.merage.uci.edu. There’s a contradiction with the September 2007 “draft” advising not to cite or distribute, while the document has officially been published on the PCIC web site.

1 Comment


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • RSS qoto.org/@daviding (Mastodon)

  • RSS on IngBrief

    • Goal, objective, ideal, pursuits (Ackoff & Emery, 1972)
      While Ackoff’s definitions of goals, objectives and ideals have been republished (and rewritten) multiple times, the 1972 definitions were derived from his original dissertation work.  Accordingly, in addition to the human-readable definitions, some mathematical notation is introduced. — begin paste — OUTCOMES 2.30. End (an immediate intended outcome) of a subject A in a particular […]
    • Pure Inquiring Systems: Antiteleology | The Design of Inquiring Systems | C. West Churchman | 1971
      The fifth way of knowing, as described by West Churchman, is a Singerian inquiring system. (This fifth way of knowing is more colloquially called Unbounded Systems Thinking in Mitroff and Linstone (1993)). The book On Purposeful Systems (Ackoff and Emery, 1972) was derived by Ackoff’s dissertation that was controversially coauthored with West Churchman. Purpose can […]
    • Process-Function Ecology, Wicked Problems, Ecological Evolution | Vasishth | Spanda J | 2015
      Understanding Process-Function Ecology by Ashwani Vasishth leads to luminaries in the systems sciences, including C. West Churchman, Eugene P. Odum and Timothy F.H. Allen.
    • The Innovation Delusion | Lee Vinsel, Andrew L. Russell | 2020
      As an irony, the 2020 book, The Innovation Delusion by #LeeVinsel @STS_News + #AndrewLRussell @RussellProf shouldn’t be seen as an innovation, but an encouragement to join @The_Maintainers where an ongoing thought network can continue. The subtitle “How Our Obsession with the New has Disrupted the Work That Matters Most” recognizes actual innovation, as distinct from […]
    • Republishing on Facebook as “good for the world” or “bad for the world” (NY Times, 2020/11/24)
      An online social network reproduces content partially based on algorithms, and partially based on the judgements made by human beings. Either may be viewed as positive or negative. > The trade-offs came into focus this month [November 2020], when Facebook engineers and data scientists posted the results of a series of experiments called “P(Bad for […]
    • 1969, 1981 Emery, System Thinking: Selected Readings
      Social Systems Science graduate students in 1970s-1980s with #RussellAckoff, #EricTrist + #HasanOzbehkhan at U. Pennsylvania Wharton School were assigned the Penguin paperback #SystemsThinking reader edited by #FredEEmery, with updated editions evolving contents.
  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • RSS on daviding.com

    • 2021/08 Moments August 2021
      Easing into a more regular schedule, enjoying seasonable summer afternoons, with extra couples time on the weekends.
    • 2021/07 Moments July 2021
      Summer in the city with temperate weather, without the usual crowd scenes for summer festivals.
    • 2021/06 Moments June 2021
      Early summer weather, with a city gradually emerging from pandemic shutdown orders given by the Province of Ontario.
    • 2021/05 Moments May 2012
      Brighter days of spring, with slight dips in temperature to remind us our four-seasons climate.
    • 2021/04 Moments April 2021
      Short bike rides around town, in variable spring weather under pandemic stay-at-home orders,
    • 2021/03 Moments March 2021
      Days brightening and temperatures above freezing, optimism with vaccinations against the pandemic.
  • RSS on Media Queue

  • Meta

  • Creative Commons License
    This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License
    Theme modified from DevDmBootstrap4 by Danny Machal